Author |
Message |
|
This is the so called club of "participants requesting a new app".
As the availability of the Pascal GPUs increasing, its price is reducing bit by bit, it is time to have a GPUGrid app which supports these GPUs.
I think the current app would work fine if it would include this "nonbonded.cu" module for CC6.1 cards.
(So it won't have to be a CUDA8 app, perhaps if it would be CUDA8 it could be even faster.)
Everyone who already owns such a GPU, or placed an order for such a GPU, or planning to buy one:
Please post the number and type of your Pascal GPU here
to help us to assess the amount of computing power this project could have, and the amount of the energy could have been saved.
I hope this will give sufficient motivation for the staff, at least to communicate more about their plans & progress.
I have a GTX 1080 up and running. |
|
|
Lluis Send message
Joined: 22 Feb 14 Posts: 26 Credit: 672,639,304 RAC: 0 Level
![Lysine - More than 500M credits Lys](img/badges/aa/badge_lys.png) Scientific publications
![Top 50% (1208th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 75% (1792nd/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 75% (1998th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 25% (453rd/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 25% (1169th/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (80th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (82nd/1348) contribution to Doerr et al, JCTC 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 25% (482nd/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (137th/1656) contribution to Kapoor et al., Sci Rep 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 75% (987th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 50% (499th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 50% (374th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 10% (260th/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
Great idea for the "Wish list"
I'm planning to buy a GTX 1070 (upgrade from GTX 660) as soon as the new app for Pascal GPU is ready. |
|
|
|
You can count me in...
I'm planning on getting the mini-ITX card of the 1070 made by gigabyte as an upgrade from my GTX 650Ti BOOST. I've already started making a spare stash of money for it, although the price is still unknown... doesn't hurt to save, though.
|
|
|
|
I have set aside 1k for the Pascal Titan, which last I heard was rumored to come out end of summer early/fall. |
|
|
skgivenVolunteer moderator Volunteer tester
![Avatar](https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/77be8b04dc35f6033048abca3f3803c4?s=100&d=identicon) Send message
Joined: 23 Apr 09 Posts: 3968 Credit: 1,995,359,260 RAC: 0 Level
![Histidine - More than 1.5B credits His](img/badges/aa/badge_his.png) Scientific publications
![Top 100% (2761st/2932) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 75% (1680th/2466) contribution to Sadiq et al, Proteins 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 10% (266th/3118) contribution to Selent et al, PLoS Comput Biol 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (15th/4410) contribution to Buch et al, PNAS 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (22nd/2450) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (15th/9662) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3113) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput, 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (14th/5798) contribution to Sadiq et al, PNAS 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 25% (352nd/1995) contribution to Venken et al, JCTC 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 1% (15th/3349) contribution to Buch et al, JCIM 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (49th/3864) contribution to Dainese et al, Biochem. J. 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (62nd/4477) contribution to Pérez-Hernández et al, JCP 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (70th/2163) contribution to Bisignano et al. JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (14th/1283) contribution to Doerr et al. JCTC 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (45th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (18th/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (34th/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (49th/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (105th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 100% (1222nd/1348) contribution to Doerr et al, JCTC 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 1% (35th/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 50% (485th/1656) contribution to Kapoor et al., Sci Rep 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 10% (50th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 75% (551st/1022) contribution to Wang et al., ACS Cent. Sci. 2019 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 25% (307th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (29th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (334th/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
Keep saving - the Pascal Titan will cost ~$1200 (due 2nd Aug).
____________
FAQ's
HOW TO:
- Opt out of Beta Tests
- Ask for Help |
|
|
Beyond![Avatar](https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/026deda0a0d87168ee4e605155a8e102?s=100&d=identicon) Send message
Joined: 23 Nov 08 Posts: 1112 Credit: 6,162,416,256 RAC: 0 Level
![Tyrosine - More than 5B credits Tyr](img/badges/aa/badge_tyr.png) Scientific publications
![Top 25% (348th/2932) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 25% (281st/2466) contribution to Sadiq et al, Proteins 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (165th/3118) contribution to Selent et al, PLoS Comput Biol 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (133rd/4410) contribution to Buch et al, PNAS 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (45th/2450) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (42nd/9662) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (119th/5798) contribution to Sadiq et al, PNAS 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (17th/2163) contribution to Bisignano et al. JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (19th/1283) contribution to Doerr et al. JCTC 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (19th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (148th/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (49th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (8th/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (124th/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (6th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (7th/1348) contribution to Doerr et al, JCTC 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (9th/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (9th/1656) contribution to Kapoor et al., Sci Rep 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (15th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (17th/1022) contribution to Wang et al., ACS Cent. Sci. 2019 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 25% (137th/672) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (140th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (11th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (71st/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
Keep saving - the Pascal Titan will cost ~$1200 (due 2nd Aug).
That's obscene. Will it be as slow as the last Titan? |
|
|
skgivenVolunteer moderator Volunteer tester
![Avatar](https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/77be8b04dc35f6033048abca3f3803c4?s=100&d=identicon) Send message
Joined: 23 Apr 09 Posts: 3968 Credit: 1,995,359,260 RAC: 0 Level
![Histidine - More than 1.5B credits His](img/badges/aa/badge_his.png) Scientific publications
![Top 100% (2761st/2932) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 75% (1680th/2466) contribution to Sadiq et al, Proteins 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 10% (266th/3118) contribution to Selent et al, PLoS Comput Biol 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (15th/4410) contribution to Buch et al, PNAS 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (22nd/2450) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (15th/9662) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3113) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput, 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (14th/5798) contribution to Sadiq et al, PNAS 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 25% (352nd/1995) contribution to Venken et al, JCTC 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 1% (15th/3349) contribution to Buch et al, JCIM 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (49th/3864) contribution to Dainese et al, Biochem. J. 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (62nd/4477) contribution to Pérez-Hernández et al, JCP 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (70th/2163) contribution to Bisignano et al. JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (14th/1283) contribution to Doerr et al. JCTC 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (45th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (18th/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (34th/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (49th/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (105th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 100% (1222nd/1348) contribution to Doerr et al, JCTC 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 1% (35th/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 50% (485th/1656) contribution to Kapoor et al., Sci Rep 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 10% (50th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 75% (551st/1022) contribution to Wang et al., ACS Cent. Sci. 2019 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 25% (307th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (29th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (334th/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
Yeah, crazy money for a GPU. Quite obscene and not something I would consider forking out for.
That said scientists will be able to build a 44TFlops CUDA research rig for $6000 to $8K. When I was working in various labs lost of research equipment cost tens if not hundreds of £K and some >>more than that. So, for R&D it's good, but not for DC.
For us here, scaling was an issue with the GTX 980Ti so I'm expecting it to be an issue with anything roughly that big with Pascal too (1080 upwards).
By scaling I mean actual throughput performance doesn't increase linearly with the GFlops of bigger cards.
In theory the Titan P will be ~24% faster than the 1080 but despite the favourable Bus width and Bus/GFlops ratio, scaling is likely to be a factor.
Then there's the silly price tag and the fact that two MSRP 1080's would cost the same as one Titan P Founders Ed and offer 60% more GFlops.
Finally, we don't yet know how the Pascal's perform here relative to the GTX 900 series or each other.
IMO the whole NV GTX1000 range is too costly at present and will likely stay high for some time, mostly due to the lack of availability. For most people here the 1060 might be the most attractive, when the price is right and when the drivers support the apps use of CUDA8...
____________
FAQ's
HOW TO:
- Opt out of Beta Tests
- Ask for Help |
|
|
|
Any Chance that support for my 2 Titan Vs will be added? Right now all I get is a computation error.
____________
|
|
|