Author |
Message |
|
I doubt it's possible, but I would love to be able to
dedicate my 560ti to the long queue and my
460 (in the same system) to the short queue.
Instead of the current scenario where we can only
choose 1 or the other.
maybe give donors the ability to set up a profile,
so we can dedicate task types to different GPUs on
our systems.
I know that that would take an awful lot of work to
program the servers to be able to do that, but hey
this is a wish list right ;) |
|
|
|
I'd expect that to require changes to BOINC, not just to GPUGRID. Some other people with more that one GPU per computer might want that too, though.
Another idea: If the motherboard has a separate GPU for use when there is no graphics board, how hard would it be to make BOINC use that GPU also (probably not for GPUGRID)? |
|
|
skgivenVolunteer moderator Volunteer tester
![Avatar](https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/77be8b04dc35f6033048abca3f3803c4?s=100&d=identicon) Send message
Joined: 23 Apr 09 Posts: 3968 Credit: 1,995,359,260 RAC: 0 Level
![Histidine - More than 1.5B credits His](img/badges/aa/badge_his.png) Scientific publications
![Top 100% (2761st/2932) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 75% (1680th/2466) contribution to Sadiq et al, Proteins 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 10% (266th/3118) contribution to Selent et al, PLoS Comput Biol 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (15th/4410) contribution to Buch et al, PNAS 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (22nd/2450) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (15th/9662) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3113) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput, 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (14th/5798) contribution to Sadiq et al, PNAS 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 25% (352nd/1995) contribution to Venken et al, JCTC 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 1% (15th/3349) contribution to Buch et al, JCIM 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (49th/3864) contribution to Dainese et al, Biochem. J. 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (62nd/4477) contribution to Pérez-Hernández et al, JCP 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (70th/2163) contribution to Bisignano et al. JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (14th/1283) contribution to Doerr et al. JCTC 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (45th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (18th/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (34th/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (49th/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (105th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 100% (1222nd/1348) contribution to Doerr et al, JCTC 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 1% (35th/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 50% (485th/1656) contribution to Kapoor et al., Sci Rep 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 10% (50th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 75% (551st/1022) contribution to Wang et al., ACS Cent. Sci. 2019 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 25% (307th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (29th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (334th/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
Simba123, I'm not sure about this and I can't test it (as I don't have mixed cards in the one system). I think you would need to select to crunch long and normal length tasks, and setup a cc_config file something like this:
<cc_config>
<options>
<exclude_gpu>
<url>http://www.gpugrid.net/</url>
<device_num>0</device_num>
<type>nvidia</type>
<app>acemd</app>
</exclude_gpu>
<exclude_gpu>
<url>http://www.gpugrid.net/</url>
<device_num>1</device_num>
<type>nvidia</type>
<app>acemdlong</app>
</exclude_gpu>
</options>
</cc_config>
Assumes that the better GPU is device 0 (first PCIE slot)
robertmiles, use all gpu's is an option for the cc_config file,
<use_all_gpus>1</use_all_gpus>
but the issue is that most boards want you to use either the onboard/ondie GPU or the discrete GPU. Some boards do allow you to use the onboard/ondie GPU as well, but not many are boinc capable/useful. The AMD APU's are useful but it's just getting a board that can use both, and then the OpenCL projects that can use these tend to eat up lots of system resources, so you would starve the big GPU anyway. This might also work better on Windows than Linux.
Intel's latest desktop CPU's include the likes of the i7-3770K, with Intel HD Graphics 4000. These are OpenCL capable, but is there a project that can use them, and are they any use?
____________
FAQ's
HOW TO:
- Opt out of Beta Tests
- Ask for Help |
|
|
|
you got two different series to crunch boinc? because I couldnt, tho I didnt wait very long and it was on a sunday. should tell me if it works for you. |
|
|
|
Thanks for the replies,
skgiven, I will give that template a try later on.
@ Bugler.
If you mean did I get a 460 and a 560 in the same system
to crunch at the same time, yes I did.
just by using the
<use_all_gpus>1</use_all_gpus>
in the config file.
To be honest, now that the 4.2 app has cut runtimes by 40-50%, it's no longer such an issue for me as even the 460 can get long tasks in with plenty of time to spare.
I will still test that config from skgiven, out of curiosity more than anything else.
|
|
|
|
Simba123, I'm not sure about this and I can't test it (as I don't have mixed cards in the one system). I think you would need to select to crunch long and normal length tasks, and setup a cc_config file something like this:
<cc_config>
<options>
<exclude_gpu>
<url>http://www.gpugrid.net/</url>
<device_num>0</device_num>
<type>nvidia</type>
<app>acemd</app>
</exclude_gpu>
<exclude_gpu>
<url>http://www.gpugrid.net/</url>
<device_num>1</device_num>
<type>nvidia</type>
<app>acemdlong</app>
</exclude_gpu>
</options>
</cc_config>
Assumes that the better GPU is device 0 (first PCIE slot)
+1
Just what I was looking for!
P.S. short names for short runs are now acemd2 |
|
|
Chilean ![](./img/badges/donor.png) ![Avatar](https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/f41d970462a4bb280f7f2439c80a78d7?s=100&d=identicon) Send message
Joined: 8 Oct 12 Posts: 98 Credit: 385,652,461 RAC: 0 Level
![Aspartic Acid - More than 300M credits Asp](img/badges/aa/badge_asp.png) Scientific publications
![Top 25% (537th/2163) contribution to Bisignano et al. JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 50% (616th/1283) contribution to Doerr et al. JCTC 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 50% (820th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 50% (1059th/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 25% (487th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 25% (545th/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 25% (652nd/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 50% (2029th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 25% (882nd/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 50% (837th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 90% (505th/672) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_bronze.png) ![Top 50% (599th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 50% (517th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 10% (358th/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
I'd expect that to require changes to BOINC, not just to GPUGRID. Some other people with more that one GPU per computer might want that too, though.
Another idea: If the motherboard has a separate GPU for use when there is no graphics board, how hard would it be to make BOINC use that GPU also (probably not for GPUGRID)?
I've always wanted to use the NVIDIA card as a GPUGrid cruncher, and use the graphics processor in the INTEL-CPU for everyday graphics (maximizing, youtube, etc) |
|
|
|
I'd expect that to require changes to BOINC, not just to GPUGRID. Some other people with more that one GPU per computer might want that too, though.
Another idea: If the motherboard has a separate GPU for use when there is no graphics board, how hard would it be to make BOINC use that GPU also (probably not for GPUGRID)?
I've always wanted to use the NVIDIA card as a GPUGrid cruncher, and use the graphics processor in the INTEL-CPU for everyday graphics (maximizing, youtube, etc)
If you enable the onboard(CPU) graphics in your BIOS, and plug the monitor into the motherboard, the the CPU graphics will be used for display and the card can be used solely for crunching.
|
|
|
|
it is possible to run two BOINC clients on one machine, and exclude 1 card from each client. Then you configure each client as if it were its own machine.
____________
XtremeSystems.org - #1 Team in GPUGrid |
|
|
skgivenVolunteer moderator Volunteer tester
![Avatar](https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/77be8b04dc35f6033048abca3f3803c4?s=100&d=identicon) Send message
Joined: 23 Apr 09 Posts: 3968 Credit: 1,995,359,260 RAC: 0 Level
![Histidine - More than 1.5B credits His](img/badges/aa/badge_his.png) Scientific publications
![Top 100% (2761st/2932) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Inf. Model. 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 75% (1680th/2466) contribution to Sadiq et al, Proteins 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 10% (266th/3118) contribution to Selent et al, PLoS Comput Biol 2010 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (15th/4410) contribution to Buch et al, PNAS 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (22nd/2450) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (15th/9662) contribution to Buch et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3113) contribution to Giorgino et al, J. Chem. Theory Comput, 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (14th/5798) contribution to Sadiq et al, PNAS 2012 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 25% (352nd/1995) contribution to Venken et al, JCTC 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 1% (15th/3349) contribution to Buch et al, JCIM 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (49th/3864) contribution to Dainese et al, Biochem. J. 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (62nd/4477) contribution to Pérez-Hernández et al, JCP 2013 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (70th/2163) contribution to Bisignano et al. JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (14th/1283) contribution to Doerr et al. JCTC 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (45th/2838) contribution to Stanley et al, Nat Commun 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 1% (18th/3183) contribution to Lauro et al., JCIM 2014 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (27th/3611) contribution to Ferruz et al., JCIM 2015 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (34th/4128) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 1% (49th/4815) contribution to Stanley et al., Sci Rep 2016 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 10% (105th/4730) contribution to Noe et al., Nat Chem 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 100% (1222nd/1348) contribution to Doerr et al, JCTC 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_white.png) ![Top 1% (35th/4634) contribution to Martinez-Rosell et al, JCIM 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_sapphire.png) ![Top 50% (485th/1656) contribution to Kapoor et al., Sci Rep 2017 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_gold.png) ![Top 10% (50th/1885) contribution to Ferruz et al., Sci Rep 2018 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 75% (551st/1022) contribution to Wang et al., ACS Cent. Sci. 2019 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_silver.png) ![Top 25% (307th/1541) contribution to Rodriguez-Espigares et al., Nat Meth 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_ruby.png) ![Top 10% (29th/1450) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, Sci Rep 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) ![Top 10% (334th/6232) contribution to Herrera-Nieto et al, JCIM 2020 wat](img/badges/papers/badge_pub_emerald.png) |
It can be done in Linux, and you might be able to do it using a VM from a Windows system.
____________
FAQ's
HOW TO:
- Opt out of Beta Tests
- Ask for Help |
|
|